Here’s When Neuroticism Is a Mental Health Warning Sign

Learn how neuroticism shows up in daily life, when it is a sign of a mental health issue, and tools to help manage this personality trait.

Learn more about our Clinical Review Process

If you find yourself getting overly anxious when plans change or obsessively checking a text for typos before sending it, people might say you’re being “neurotic.” But what does that actually mean, and how is it related to your mental health?

In essence, these behaviors are sometimes signs of a neurotic personality trait, and other times, they’re just ways we cope with stress. Understanding the difference is key to understanding what these emotional patterns might be trying to tell you. Below, we explore what neuroticism really means—and how it might show up in everyday life.

What is neuroticism?

Neuroticism is one of the five core personality traits in the widely used Big Five personality model. The model includes:

• Openness (imagination, insight)
• Conscientiousness (organization, dependability)
• Extraversion (sociability, assertiveness)
• Agreeableness (trust, kindness)
• Neuroticism (emotional sensitivity, mood swings)

A neurotic personality tends to experience more frequent or intense negative emotions—things like anxiety, irritability, guilt, fear, or sadness. People with high neuroticism may have a lower tolerance for stress and a greater tendency to interpret everyday situations as threatening or overwhelming.

Importantly, neuroticism isn’t a diagnosis or psychological disorder—it’s a personality trait that exists on a spectrum. Everyone has some degree of neurotic tendencies, just like we all experience emotions like fear or frustration from time to time.

What causes someone to be neurotic?

There’s no single cause of neuroticism. Like most personality traits, it’s shaped by a mix of genetic, developmental, and environmental factors. Personality development, including early life experiences, plays a significant role in how neurotic traits evolve over time. For example, growing up in a critical or unpredictable environment may increase neurotic tendencies later in life.

Chronic stress, trauma, or emotional neglect can also heighten a person’s neuroticism level. Over time, this can impact personality development, potentially increasing the risk for mental health disorders, especially when left unaddressed.

Still, the presence of neurotic symptoms doesn’t mean something is “wrong.” Many people with neurotic personality traits live full, connected, and meaningful lives—especially when they have support. With time, self-awareness, and the right coping strategies, individuals can work to manage their neurotic traits and improve their emotional well-being.

How is neuroticism measured?

Psychologists often use tools like the Big Five Inventory to assess personality, including neuroticism. While formal assessments can be helpful, you can also reflect on your own patterns using sample prompts like these. Each one is typically answered on a scale from 1 (strongly disagree) to 5 (strongly agree):

• I often feel anxious or worried about things outside of my control.
• I get stressed out easily, even over small issues.
• I frequently ruminate on past mistakes or conversations.
• I am easily overwhelmed by my emotions.
• I often feel insecure or self-conscious in social situations.
• I tend to expect the worst in uncertain situations.
• I struggle to let go of negative thoughts or feelings.
• I get irritated or upset more easily than most people I know.
• I am frequently nervous or on edge.
• I find it difficult to bounce back after something upsetting happens.

These kinds of questions help highlight the presence of neurotic behaviors or thought patterns—but they’re just one piece of the puzzle. High neuroticism scores often correlate with more frequent negative feelings, such as anxiety, irritability, intense fear or worry, and sadness. However, try not to use this as a tool for self-diagnosis or to label yourself as “too emotional.” If answering these prompts leads you to feel overwhelmed or unsure, talking to a mental health professional can help you explore your experience without judgment.

How can neuroticism affect daily life?

High neuroticism levels can influence how you think, feel, and behave—especially in areas like relationships, work, and self-esteem. Here are some examples of how neuroticism can affect daily life, as shown in popular TV shows. 

Relationships

People with a neurotic personality may be more prone to insecure attachment style, conflict, jealousy, or needing constant reassurance in close relationships. Their emotional regulation can be more difficult to manage, leading to frequent misunderstandings.

Monica Geller from Friends often second-guesses herself in romantic relationships and can become controlling or anxious when things feel uncertain. While she deeply values connection, her neurotic behavior sometimes strains her interactions with others.

Work

In the workplace, people with high neuroticism may struggle with negative thought patterns, performance pressure, or conflict with coworkers. These people may also be more vulnerable to developing a mood disorder or burnout, especially in fast-paced or high-stakes environments.

George Costanza from Seinfeld is a textbook case of how neurotic traits can derail professional life. He overanalyzes everything, frequently melts down, and often self-sabotages.

Self-esteem

A neurotic person often experiences lower self-esteem, internalized stress, and constant comparison to others. They may be more susceptible to mental health conditions like depression or anxiety disorders.

Rory Gilmore from Gilmore Girls begins to struggle with her self-image when her perfectionism and self-doubt start to spiral. Her neurotic tendencies get in the way of her confidence, especially in times of change or failure.

What to know about neuroticism and co-occurring conditions

Neuroticism, according to research, is “a fundamental dimension of personality” strongly associated with increased risk for nearly all major mental disorders, including eating disorders, bipolar disorder, borderline personality disorder, and depressive disorders. Because it contributes to poor stress resilience and amplifies emotional reactivity, it can increase vulnerability to mental illness.

For example, neuroticism can predict the onset and persistence of depression – people high in neurotic traits were more likely to engage in negative thought patterns, including self-blame and rumination, which contributes to the development and maintenance of depressive symptoms or a depressive disorder.

The good news is researchers have also identified several protective factors that can buffer these risks. Psychological flexibility, strong social support, and emotional coping skills like mindfulness and self-compassion can significantly reduce the likelihood that neuroticism leads to chronic distress or mental health disorders.

Is neuroticism always a bad thing?

Not at all. Though neurotic traits are often framed negatively, they can offer surprising benefits—especially in moderation. People with a healthy dose of neuroticism tend to be emotionally attuned, thoughtful, and self-reflective. They may also take fewer risks, make more cautious decisions, and show deeper empathy.

Can neuroticism be managed or changed?

While personality disorders and traits like neuroticism are often long-lasting, they are also flexible. The key is learning to recognize your neurotic behavior without letting it control your life.

Cognitive behavioral therapy (CBT) is a popular treatment that helps people challenge negative thought patterns, manage emotional reactivity, and build self-awareness. Additional strategies include:

• Mindfulness and breathwork to regulate intense emotions
• Exercise, which can help manage stress and stabilize mood
• Routine-building, which adds predictability and structure
• Positive psychology tools like gratitude journaling or self-compassion
• Online therapy for flexible, ongoing support
• Support groups, which provide validation and shared strategies

While you might never eliminate neurotic traits altogether, you can build emotional resilience, shift your internal narrative, and strengthen your sense of control.

How Charlie Health can help

If you or a loved one are struggling with negative feelings linked to high levels of neuroticism, Charlie Health is here to help. Charlie Health’s virtual Intensive Outpatient Program (IOP) provides mental health treatment for people dealing with serious mental health conditions. Our expert clinicians incorporate evidence-based therapies into individual counseling, family therapy, and group sessions. With support, managing your mental health is possible. Fill out the form below or give us a call to start healing today.